The food was decent and clearly well prepared, but the experience didn’t justify the price. Portions were small, and the menu felt very limited, which made it hard to feel like you’re getting real value. What stood out most, though, is how this place reflects a bigger issue with dining out lately. You’re paying top dollar, but getting less of everything—smaller portions, weaker drinks, and fewer options. Charging $9 for a small piece of focaccia and serving undersized cocktails just reinforces that feeling. I had two Negronis—normally a strong drink—and didn’t feel anything at all, which says a lot. It’s starting to feel like dining out has become more about presentation and pricing than actual value. You leave spending a lot, but not satisfied. That’s disappointing, because going out to eat used to feel like a treat—now it often feels like a poor trade-off. I wouldn’t rush back.
Reviews / Ratings for Stellina
I highly recommend. Menu is small but quality is spectacular.
This place has some of the best food I've ever tasted, it was incredible. The place was a little loud and a bit too pricey, but the food was delicious!
Absolutely love sitting at the open kitchen! The seasonal menu is always to die for, the staff is always kind and attentive! My go to recommendations!
Nicolas and the entire staff provided impeccable service and exquisite attention to detail! The wine selection is extensive, and every dish we tried was flavorful, well-textured, and thoughtfully prepared. Our experience truly surpassed all expectations. We’ll definitely be back and won't hesitate to recommend it to family and friends.
We had a delicious meal last Saturday night. Beautiful restaurant with very attentive service. The vitello tonato, pasta carbonara, risotto and desserts were outstanding.
We took the tasting menu and it was amazing! Lots of food and good service from both the staff and kitchen. We sat at the kitchen bar and it was a special culinary experience!
Amazing staff Delicious food Generous portions This is what Italian food is all about
Best carbonara and tiramisu I’ve had in my life. And I’ve had a lot so trust me.
Always the most excellent service and food. Shoutout to chef Nick for going above and beyond!
Alexia and JJ were outstanding and made our night magical. Food and the vibes tres bien
Every dish was amazing. Good service too, thank you!
Amazing and fresh pasta
They charge us for one small slice of bread and water never heard of this 🥺🥴
I am writing this review quite late, as my visit was about a year and a half ago, so things may have changed since then. Based on my experience, however, this was one of the worst restaurants I have been to in Montreal. The pasta was not properly cooked, and our orders were mixed up. I asked for no bacon, yet my husband received the bacon free dish instead. We were also charged for bread, which is almost unheard of in an Italian restaurant. Prices were extremely high for what was offered. With two pasta dishes and one or two appetizers, the bill was easily around 200 dollars. The only reason I am giving two stars is the location. The Old Port is beautiful, but I would recommend trying other restaurants instead.
Pasta and food is top!
Very good experience! They squeezed us in despite the rush. The waitress Ariana was really helpful and friendly and she elevated our dining experience.
Reviews are also available in French.
See reviews in FrenchAdd a review
Share your experience in seconds.
Opening hours
- Sunday 17:00 - 22:30
- Monday Closed
- Tuesday Closed
- Wednesday Closed
- Thursday Closed
- Friday Closed
- Saturday 17:00 - 23:00
Missing information?
Help us improve this restaurant profile.
Update the profile