Restaurant profile

Sal's Famous Pizzeria Inc.

1028 East Main Street · Brownsburg · J1J 1J1 Add a photo
(317) 858-8700
Visit web site
48 evaluations
Menus Reviews Restaurant owner?
Report this closed restaurant
Sal's Famous Pizzeria Inc.
Sal's Famous Pizzeria Inc. 1028 East Main Street, Brownsburg
Menus Reviews Restaurant owner?
4.8
48 evaluations
Add your review
Review summary

What guests say about Sal's Famous Pizzeria Inc.

Customers mostly describe the pizza as highly appreciated, often served hot and fresh, with several other dishes also very well received. The service is frequently described as friendly, attentive, and efficient, and the atmosphere is often called pleasant and welcoming. A few reviews, however, mention that some dishes can occasionally be bland, service can be slow at times, and prices are considered high.

Summary based on 48 reviews.

Reviews / Ratings for Sal's Famous Pizzeria Inc.

Photo of Nancy Hodges
4 Jun 2026
Source: Google
5.0

Great food. Great service, the remodel at Brownsburg looks awesome.

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of Connie Dragoo
25 May 2026
Source: Google
5.0

The pizza was EXCELLENT!!

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of Elaine Roetter
24 May 2026
Source: Google
5.0

we carried out, but noticed that you have remodeled. It looks great. You have the best woodfire pizza and fettucinie alfredo to Indy area. Keep doing what your doing! Eline & Shelly Brownsburg

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of Steve Pollom
24 May 2026
Source: Google
4.7

Excellent Veal Picatta. Web site for on line ordering is very good and easy to navigate. Ordered to pick up at 6:15 and it was ready to go

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of Brandon Granger
22 May 2026
Source: Google
5.0

I would totally recommend the deep dish pizza! This pizza will feed a family of 4 at only $18! The crust was so crunchy and soft if you dip a piece in the olive oil at the table it taste so amazing!

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of Nick Leonard
20 May 2026
Source: Google
5.0

Dine in or carry out the wood fired pizza are a family favorite. Pizza by the slice makes for the best quick lunch in Brownsburg. Highly recommend

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of Jase Stone
16 May 2026
Source: Google
5.0

James is the man !!!

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of Alicia Page
15 May 2026
Source: Google
5.0

Excellent food and excellent service!

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of Eric Palmer
12 May 2026
Source: Google
3.3

We got to Sal‘s around 7 o’clock on Monday and even though they were supposed to be open till 10 o’clock they started clearing things off the table as we ate even though it was not busy at all. For example, the table light there was no salt and pepper at the table. They finally did bring some salt and they also cleared off the bread seasoning.. It was just very odd that they would start clearing as we were still eating.

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Restaurant response
Response added on 14 May 2026
Thank you for your feedback. We are sorry your experience felt uncomfortable during your visit. We’d like to clarify that our team was simply trying to maintain a clean dining environment and was not attempting to rush you while you were eating. Regarding the salt and pepper, we normally do keep them on every table however, that evening we were in the process of washing and sanitizing all of our shakers, which is why they were temporarily unavailable. We were happy to provide as request. we also appreciate you mentioning the table clearing while our staff was only trying to keep the dining area tidy we understand how it may come across during your meal and will be more mindful moving forward to ensure guest feel relaxed, and comfortable while dining with us Thank you again for your feedback and we hope to welcome you back again soon!
Photo of Crista Wilkins
10 May 2026
Source: Google
4.3

Caprese salad was ok, because the tomatoes weren't ripe enough. The 4 Stragoni was really really good!

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of Megan Martin
9 May 2026
Source: Google
5.0

Great food, great service, great atmosphere.

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of Beth Francis
8 May 2026
Source: Google
5.0

Great place for a group birthday!

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of Mike Floyd
4 May 2026
Source: Google
5.0

Everytime we order for pickup, the food is fresh and is hot. Nice, friendly staff. We eat here often.

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of Brenda Bennett
1 May 2026
Source: Google
5.0

Sal’s is like family and Nathan is my baby brother. 😊 great food, lovely restaurant that soothes my soul.

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of Michael Peterson
28 Apr 2026
Source: Google
3.0

Food was decent but pricey. Staff seemed sullen and overworked. Vibes a bit off but maybe I'm reading too much into it. Great menu selection. Happy to go back and try again. My request is that management treats staff better and the prices go down by about 10%.

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of Madelynn Krauss
27 Apr 2026
Source: Google
5.0

Marilyn was my server and she made me feel extra taken care of and remembered my order, very very good at her job

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of Meredith Beck
25 Apr 2026
Source: Google
5.0

We ate divine gnocchi and pizza calzone along with salads. Lovely atmosphere, delicious food and James was very attentive. Can't wait to return!.

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of Tammy Esenwein
24 Apr 2026
Source: Google
5.0

Had a wonderful evening meal with friends. The staff was attentive and friendly. The newly remodeled Brownsburg is beautiful. Delicious food, lovely ambiance. Looking forward to our next time there.

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of C B
23 Apr 2026
Source: Google
3.0

Pizza had no flavor and barely any cheese. Was surprised at how bland it was., enough that we quit eating it. Then the bill came and items were $2 higher than on the menu. The menu is already very overpriced and this just added to dissatisfaction.

Service
Cooking
Photo of Jack Life
23 Apr 2026
Source: Google
5.0

This place is awesome!! The food is absolutelly delicious, helpful and friendly staff, great service and a clean place! One of the best restaurants I've been to.

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of Angie Crouch
18 Apr 2026
Source: Google
5.0

Love their pizza and hubby really like the trout! Server was really sweet!

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of Gregory French
29 Mar 2026
Source: Google
3.7

Has been a few years since last time eating here. Blackchalk board showed a discount for veterans so just asked about it. Hostess stated new management doesn't offer it, so why not remove it from the sign? Food was ok but didn't taste as good as we remembered. Service was great along with the atmosphere.

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Restaurant response
Response added on 11 Apr 2026
Dear Gregory, We appreciate your feedback! Apologies about the misunderstanding. We are pleased to announce that we have removed the chalkboard. We would simply like to clarify the misunderstanding and clarify that the sign was erased at the moment and also said happy Veterans Day. We have taken up the matter and are thrilled to inform all our veterans that we will now not only on Veterans Day but every day be able to offer a discount in appreciation to those who served and currently serve. As always we appreciate the service and simply want to give back to the community. We hope to see you in soon!
Photo of Elizabeth Ann
23 Mar 2026
Source: Google
3.7

I do takeout but the atmosphere always seems pleasant. I have had many fantastic pies from here and lately 1 that was terrible. There was a problem when I ordered via the phone so I had to reorder in the restaurant so the pie was rushed. The crust wasn't as crispy as usual so I was a little disappointed. This was a complete one-off for them so no worries, I went back the week after and the pie was great

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of TJ Strawmyer
18 Mar 2026
Source: Google
5.0

Akyra was so sweet and took good care of us! Food was excellent as always!

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of Lisa Peet
14 Mar 2026
Source: Google
5.0

Our server, Akyra was fantastic!!

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere

Add a review

Share your experience in seconds.

0/500
Your review will be published immediately.

Opening hours

Opening hours
  • Sunday Closed
  • Monday 11:00 - 22:00
  • Tuesday 11:00 - 22:00
  • Wednesday 11:00 - 22:00
  • Thursday 11:00 - 22:00
  • Friday 11:00 - 22:00
  • Saturday 11:00 - 22:00

Features

Services
Dining room Food Delivery Reservation accepted Take out Wheelchair accessible
Cooking Kinds
Vegetarian
Meal Kinds
Dinner Lunch

Missing information?

Help us improve this restaurant profile.

Update the profile