Pizza Toni - Saint Henri

Jesse Gordon

17 May 2026

Source: Google

2.0

I really love the pizza here and at the other location and it always hits the mark in terms of flavour. Square pep is my favourite slice in the city and it isn’t even close. My one issue with this location in particular is that I’ve come multiple times for dinner around 6-6:30 on Sundays and have found the variety and availability of slices to be extremely lacking. Came today and there were no pizzas in the case, only 1 round pepperoni pizza available for slices. This isn’t the first time I’ve come and seen the display case basically empty. Obviously a testament to people loving the pizza and many full pie orders coming through but very disappointed that this has happened multiple times. Staff however have been super nice every single time when it happens but it’s just happened too often unfortunately

Rick Derrico (17 reviews)

16 May 2026

Source: Google

1.0

First time trying Pizza Toni. I’ve been dying to try this place for a while now and I was greatly disappointed. Took over an hour and a half for 2 small pizzas and when we got it both crusts were burnt. No point in paying extra for a sesame seed crust if the crust is burnt. No quality control being done here as a pizza this burnt should not be served.

ilene polansky (1 review)

13 May 2026

Source: Google

5.0

Zacks and staff are the best Soooooo good !!

A.Mohammad Vaziri (2 reviews)

13 May 2026

Source: Google

5.0

It was amazing. The best in the city.

GMA Blueprint - Mike (630 reviews)

11 May 2026

Source: Google

3.0

Pizza Toni run tonight. Two 18" pies = $80. Inflation said “ciao.” Pickup time: 1 hour. Reality: “Come back in 15.” Eight cooks in the kitchen, two people eating inside, and somehow my basil still came out crispy like a campfire marshmallow. Honey + sesame crust was great… the rest? Tough, burnt, and not giving what the reviews promised. We still ate it, but joy was not included.

Christelle Fares (36 reviews)

11 May 2026

Source: Google

4.0

Ordered 3 large pizzas and they were super tasty. Perfect for home and friends gathering. Why 4 stars the dough for me was not the best. I have had better. For those who like super skin crust. You’ll love it

Brrshup (18 reviews)

10 May 2026

Source: Google

5.0

We ordered through uber eats. Pizza was still really good. Sometimes a little inconsistant but still very good. Have not been in the shop in st henri but have beem at the original spot. Id suggest to always go in shop and try a slice, its always fresh and so crispy lol. Overall great pizza whether you eat in or get delivered

Willis Curtis (20 reviews)

10 May 2026

Source: Google

5.0

Thank you for the good pizza

Alexander Mangano (1 review)

9 May 2026

Source: Google

5.0

Great pizza

Sebree Laurie (6 reviews)

5 May 2026

Source: Google

5.0

Finally some good pizza I can enjoy and they have vegan cheese! Bit pricey, the wait for it is long but the pizza is delicious and the people there are very chill and welcoming. Definitely will be back for another slice! 🍕

Jessica Navar (28 reviews)

4 May 2026

Source: Google

4.7

We really enjoyed the square pepperoni pizza, it was amazing! We got it with the spicy honey dip. Cute spot, lots of places to sit.

L. Berardi (29 reviews)

3 May 2026

Source: Google

4.0

Subtle sarcasm 😉

Júlia Gaspar (32 reviews)

2 May 2026

Source: Google

5.0

I was just in New York and ate at L’industrie (considered the best pizza there right now). THIS IS BETTER!!! I couldn’t believe myself either…but it is. Insanely tasty. Get the garlic sauce too.

Jeremy Hill (15 reviews)

1 May 2026

Source: Google

5.0

Great service and pizza

Chris (8 reviews)

29 Apr 2026

Source: Google

5.0

Best in town, hands down

Rocko Paolo (20 reviews)

25 Apr 2026

Source: Google

4.3

Decided to try a slice at this sparsely decorated space. I had a slice that was heated on the spot. The crust was perfectly crisp. The sauce was great. It reminded me of a place in Verdun that made NY pizza that closed. Delicious pizza.

Waseem-.- Murad (16 reviews)

25 Apr 2026

Source: Google

5.0

One of the pest pizza 🍕 in montreal I thank Omar, the person at the cashier, for suggesting the pizza.

Ianna Javellana (6 reviews)

24 Apr 2026

Source: Google

5.0

Great pizza and great service!! WWW

Samantha M (6 reviews)

19 Apr 2026

Source: Google

5.0

Best pizza in Montreal hands down! Must try!!!

Sergey B (25 reviews)

18 Apr 2026

Source: Google

1.0

Ever since they started to sell extra toppings their base layer is so thin that the bread comes to you dried as a wine cork. Been ordering from there for over past 3 years on regular basis, for one day to be ripped off and i had even ordered extra cherry tomatoes, which were not there. Have the delivery guy eat to the toppings? Come on! 😂

Pepi Paraskevopoulos (51 reviews)

16 Apr 2026

Source: Google

5.0

One of the best pizzas I have ever tasted!

Henry Craven-Shreenan (20 reviews)

14 Apr 2026

Source: Google

3.0

Pizza toni what happened? I went in today for some slices, and I was absolutely astounded by the price 15$ for two slices no drink, no dip, no parm. Just a dirty chili flake shaker and some napkins. I mean fair enough when you have 9! People on staff flipping pies and tweaking out but comon?!?! Ridonkulous. (Edit) saying it's 2026 is an amazing response. good job I was un aware of the year. And yes I stand by the melon review. That pizza was fresh, delicious and I seem to remember it didn't cost 15$ for two dry slices of pie. It may be the same pizza under your brand but the difference was extreme. Jacking up the prices AND putting out a worse product expecting people to not say anything is crazy. Always blame the year not your approach, excellent strategy for growth.

Michael Terlecki (20 reviews)

14 Apr 2026

Source: Google

5.0

As a local Montrealer this is hands down the best slice in the city!! I’ve tried them all!!!

Michael C (213 reviews)

11 Apr 2026

Source: Google

5.0

Great service from Edan!

Julia Bernstein (2 reviews)

9 Apr 2026

Source: Google

5.0

First time at Pizza Toni and it knocked my socks off. Ordered the vodka pepperoni and it was the best pizza in the city (imo) Don’t miss out on the cookies… they are AMAZING. Shoutout to Tommy for the great rec & kind service! We will 100% be back.