4.7
93 evaluations
Add your review
Review summary

What guests say about Jack Astor's Bar & Grill Dorval

Overall, Jack Astor’s Bar & Grill Dorval receives a lot of praise for its friendly atmosphere, especially for family outings or watching a game, with decor and activities appreciated by many customers. Service very often stands out as a strength, with several servers described as attentive, fast, and friendly. The food is generally well liked, especially the burgers, wings, nachos, and some chicken dishes, but a few reviews mention order mistakes, dishes sometimes being overcooked, or uneven quality. Some customers also find the prices high or the music too loud, while others regret the removal of certain menu items.

Summary based on 86 reviews.

Reviews / Ratings for Jack Astor's Bar & Grill Dorval

Photo of Jess L
21 May 2026
Source: Google
2.0

Very disappointing experience with our server, Gaby. We didn’t even get offered water, and there was barely any interaction throughout the meal. After the food was brought out, nobody came back to check if everything was okay. The only time Gaby came back to our table was after we were already done eating to ask if we needed anything else. The food tasted decent, but my pasta was lukewarm while my husband’s meal came out hot, which honestly made me jealous. The chicken in my pasta also had burnt edges, and despite paying extra for bacon and mushrooms, there was barely any bacon included. The service seemed heavily focused on the other side of the restaurant, even though the hockey game hadn’t even started yet. My drink was also mostly ice, which felt like a waste of money. What disappointed me the most was at the end of the meal. I still had leftovers, and instead of asking if I wanted a takeout container like most servers usually do, Gaby cleared my plate and stacked another person’s dirty plate on top of mine, making it obvious I couldn’t bring it home anymore. She did offer to replace it afterward without charging me, which I appreciated, because honestly if she hadn’t offered that, I probably wouldn’t have left a tip. Definitely hesitant to come back after this experience.

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Restaurant response
Response added on 21 May 2026
Hello Jess L, thank you for sharing your feedback. We always strive to provide an excellent dining experience, and I'm sorry to hear your visit was so disappointing. Can you please email us at [email protected] so that we can reach out to you directly to apologize and address your concerns? Please remember to include a copy of your review and let us know the username it’s under. Bryan Bird, General Manager
Photo of Cesar Silva
20 May 2026
Source: Google
5.0

Amazing experience at Jack Astor’s! The food was delicious, everything tasted fresh and full of flavor. The service was exceptional super friendly, attentive, and fast. Definitely one of those places where you enjoy both the food and the atmosphere. Highly recommended!

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of Carl Hiltz
18 May 2026
Source: Google
5.0

Excellent service by Julia visited by the manager Stacy very clean excellent steak excellent service

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of Sam Szaroz
13 May 2026
Source: Google
5.0

Dylan was the BEEZ KNEEZ!! I couldn't ask for better service when I showed up mid game and peak service!! A real 10 / 10 experience and thats says alot since I've been coming to this place for over 10 years!! Thank you!

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of Rebecca
12 May 2026
Source: Google
5.0

We had a great time dining at Jacks! Our server, Cyann was beyond lovely. She was helpful and attentive. Thank you!

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of shahrokh
10 May 2026
Source: Google
4.7

We had a great experience at Jack Astor's Bar & Grill. Mikhail was very friendly, attentive, and provided excellent service throughout our visit. Thank you for the great hospitality!

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of DevinBrodie25
9 May 2026
Source: Google
3.7

Great family restaurant in the West Island. Very good Steak and burger for the price. Fun atmosphere.

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of Jaclyn Bercovitch
8 May 2026
Source: Google
4.7

Jack Asters used to be 5 stars but unfortunately they took away the beer and cheddar soup, this was a staple! It was one of the best soups and we would order Jack Asters specifically for the soup. Please bring it back! 🙏🏻

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of Mike Saper
5 May 2026
Source: Google
5.0

Great place to watch the Habs strive towards the World Cup!! Gabby our server was the best !! The crab/lobster dip was just perfect !

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of Rodney Marks
26 Apr 2026
Source: Google
4.3

If you're looking for a festive (they had Christmas lights lit) environment,to have quick draft or pint...then this place is for you 😁. I was there to have supper with friends. They chose this place, I personally prefer a more upscale establishment. If you like burgers and fries.. nachos.. chicken wings,then you'll love this place. Our serving girl was young and polite, but failed bring napkins or cutlery before our entree arrived.😞 .lastly they didn't have Modelo or Heineken, which I feel, for a pub/restaurant is a major fail.

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of Jennifer Pier
21 Apr 2026
Source: Google
4.0

I was disappointed with my recent visit. The salad I was served was not fresh, parts of it were already turning brown. On top of that, the plate it was served in did not appear clean; it had greasy marks with visible residue and marks. This raised concerns for me about overall cleanliness and food quality. I hope more attention is given to both freshness and proper dishwashing. On a positive note, the servers were very professional, kind, and attentive to specific requests. Because of their service, I’m giving 3 stars. However, the issues with cleanliness and food freshness need serious attention from management.

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Restaurant response
Response added on 21 Apr 2026
Hello Jennifer Pier, thank you for sharing your feedback. We always strive to provide an excellent dining experience, and I'm sorry to hear that your meal was so disappointing. Can you please email us at [email protected] so that we can reach out to you directly to apologize and address your concerns? Please remember to include a copy of your review and let us know the username it’s under. Bryan Bird, General Manager
Photo of Richard Sheppard
18 Apr 2026
Source: Google
5.0

Elisha our server provided my daughter and I amazing service. She was very helpful and gave great suggestions for food choices. She also made my daughter very happy.

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of Mike O'Reilly
18 Apr 2026
Source: Google
4.7

I was there for supper with my 2 boys. Food was good as usual, and Dylan's service was top notch

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of Élizabeth Bertrand
18 Apr 2026
Source: Google
4.3

Kind and very mindful of tight schedule

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of Charles Addington
18 Apr 2026
Source: Google
4.3

Dylan was an awesome server. He was positive, helpful and quick to revisit the table and check in!

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of Thomas Legrand
18 Apr 2026
Source: Google
5.0

Always good at Jack’s! Great service

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of Stefanie Perra
18 Apr 2026
Source: Google
5.0

Gaby and Dylan were awesome

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of Alex
18 Apr 2026
Source: Google
5.0

We are regulars at this Jacks location. Amazing staff. In particular Syeda is brilliant, can’t say enough good things.

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of pierre bruno
10 Apr 2026
Source: Google
3.0

No healthy choices. Burger patties not juicy, overcooked or reheate.

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Restaurant response
Response added on 10 Apr 2026
Hello pierre, thank you for sharing your feedback. We always strive to provide an excellent dining experience, and I'm sorry to hear that your meal was so disappointing. Can you please email us at [email protected] so that we can reach out to you directly to apologize and address your concerns? Please remember to include a copy of your review and let us know the username it’s under. Bryan Bird, General Manager
Photo of Peter Pug
7 Apr 2026
Source: Google
4.3

Burgers were grreat! Thaĩla made the evening fun while watching the game!! Will be back!!

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of Massi Pugliese
7 Apr 2026
Source: Google
5.0

We were not supposed to go to jack astor’s, but we ended up making the right choice! Thaïla was our server and she was very welcoming and sociable! She suggested the smoky bbq burger and it was amazing, great service overall

Atmosphere
Photo of Matthew Kennedy
7 Apr 2026
Source: Google
5.0

Great place for the whole family!

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of Mikhail Lopez
5 Apr 2026
Source: Google
4.7

I had a great experience at Jack Astor's. There's many different food options and it's a fun atmosphere. The standout is definitely the service!! Thank you Thaïla for the great vibes all night!

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of M
4 Apr 2026
Source: Google
5.0

Food was great, had the calamari and Mac n cheese. Great service by our waiter Ante!

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere
Photo of Jack Shields
4 Apr 2026
Source: Google
5.0

Went to Jack Astor’s the other night, food was great and the vibe was on point. Shoutout to our waiter Ante — super friendly and took really good care of us. Made the whole experience even better. Definitely going back

Service
Cooking
Atmosphere

Reviews are also available in French.

See reviews in French

Add a review

Share your experience in seconds.

0/500
Your review will be published immediately.

Opening hours

Dining room
  • Sunday 12:00 - 22:00
  • Monday 11:30 - 22:00
  • Tuesday 11:30 - 22:00
  • Wednesday 11:30 - 22:00
  • Thursday 11:30 - 22:00
  • Friday 11:30 - 23:00
  • Saturday 12:00 - 23:00

Missing information?

Help us improve this restaurant profile.

Update the profile