Il Teatro Restaurant Italien - Place D'Youville

laurita ikorineza (1 review)

10 May 2026

Source: Google

4.0

Nice selection of appetizers, pizza and cacio e Pepe was great , also favourite drink was the “passion fever”

Dylan Ellerton (13 reviews)

4 May 2026

Source: Google

3.0

I really wanted to enjoy my experience here, but I found myself somewhat conflicted. On a positive note, the tagliatelle ai funghi was well executed and quite enjoyable, with the only minor critique being that it leaned slightly on the salty side. The soup of the day was also pleasant, though not particularly memorable. Unfortunately, the cacio e pepe fell short of expectations. It is a dish we are quite familiar with, and this version was overwhelmingly salty to the point that it detracted significantly from the overall flavor. Additionally, it was disappointing to learn that there was no focaccia available during our visit. Overall, while there were some highlights, the inconsistency in seasoning and limited availability of certain items made the experience less satisfying than anticipated.

Roland Guy (4 reviews)

29 Apr 2026

Source: Google

5.0

Super cool vibe in old theatre. Great food, Service and ambiance!

Suzanne Giguere (3 reviews)

31 Mar 2026

Source: Google

5.0

Excellent service!

NT Dinh (18 reviews)

27 Feb 2026

Source: Google

5.0

Excellent meal with a sweet surprise for my birthday. Our family ordered the diavolo pizza, steak with tomato rigatoni (instead of potatoes), and the osso bucco with a side garden salad. Everything was delicious although perhaps a bit heavy-handed with the salt. Service was excellent. We were staring at Le Capitole hotel so this was a very convenient resto for dinner with a baby.

Sophie Omari (9 reviews)

26 Feb 2026

Source: Google

5.0

Excellent !

Restaurant response

De la part de toute l'équipe, merci pour vos bons commentaires et au plaisir de vous revoir bientôt!

Sofiia Zamnius (1 review)

9 Feb 2026

Source: Google

5.0

Everything was great! Thank you!

Restaurant response

Response added on 15 Feb 2026

Thank you so much for your good words Mrs Zamnius, we look foward to your next visit!

C Lopes (119 reviews)

7 Feb 2026

Source: Google

5.0

Beautiful place. Staff are extremely professional. Very clean bathrooms and the food was delicious.

Restaurant response

Response added on 8 Feb 2026

It makes our day to hear you had such a great time. We'll be sure to share your compliments with our staff and the chef. We're so glad the ambiance and cuisine hit the mark for you. See you again soon!

G P (34 reviews)

3 Feb 2026

Source: Google

4.7

Booked with very little notice for a party of 16. The manager (can't recall her name sorry!) and server Dorian took great call of all us, and really went out of their way to accommodate seating and fitting us all in. Ordered various apps (calamari, mozzarella, salads) and various mains and all were great. For the price range and atmosphere, nothing to complain about, would go back.

Restaurant response

Response added on 8 Feb 2026

Dear GP, thank you so much for your kind words! It was a pleasure to accommodate your group. Your children were so polite and it was a pleasure to serve them. We are thrilled that everything worked out for your party of 16 on such short notice. Thank you for choosing us, and we look forward to welcoming you back soon at the Pee-Wee Tournament in Quebec City!

Rebecca Harris (1 review)

31 Jan 2026

Source: Google

4.7

Great Birthday Dinner! Thank you

Restaurant response

Response added on 1 Feb 2026

We’re so happy to hear you had a wonderful birthday celebration with us Mrs Harris! It was a pleasure to be part of your special day, and we hope to welcome you back soon for more memorable moments.

Kamran (8 reviews)

1 Jan 2026

Source: Google

1.3

We visited this place with a group of friends and, unfortunately, our experience did not meet our expectations. While the prices were generally reasonable, the food quality was average and the service was also fairly standard. Overall, it wasn’t a memorable experience for us, and it’s unlikely that we would choose this place again

Yesenia Melo (2 reviews)

1 Jan 2026

Source: Google

3.0

Dinner for four, and only two of us had food we actually enjoyed but was nothing special. Moms shrimps were the tiniest i have ever seen, no flavor whatsoever. Service was barely there, so not attentive at all. We were looking forward to it but coming from Boston Ma we have had better attentive service in our city.

Restaurant response

Response added on 3 Jan 2026

Dear Mrs Melo, We apologize if the shrimp seemed small and lacked flavor, we use two different varieties of shrimps, nordic shrimps (the smallers ones) and Argentine shrimps (the bigger ones). We're very sorry if our service did not feel attentive. If there is an action we can take to regain your confidence or if you wish to discuss with us by email at [email protected], we will seize the opportunity to do so.

Connie Lavalle (26 reviews)

31 Dec 2025

Source: Google

5.0

Wonderful Christmas experience.

Restaurant response

Response added on 3 Jan 2026

Thank you so much for your kind words Mrs Lavalle! We’re thrilled you had a wonderful holiday experience with us. Wishing you a joyful New Year!