Athena Pizzeria

C A (23 reviews)

1 Apr 2026

Source: Google

2.7

Pizza is overrated...not as hyped up to be: flavour and texture no different than you're typical 2-for-1 parlours...except it's not a 2-for-1 and they're price is nearly equal to a wood oven alternative. Their lamb gyro was alright but tzatziki was not authentic. Ambience is to be desired: it's old and run down...nothing positive expect the TV that was playing Spotify music. The young lady however was very friendly and hospitable.

Frédérick Richard (327 reviews)

25 Mar 2026

Source: Google

5.0

Favorite pizza in Roxboro, staff is helpful. Got my order very fast. I recommend

David Foscato (4 reviews)

28 Feb 2026

Source: Google

5.0

If I could give Athena more than I would. Everything is always awesome and fresh. They tell me 30-45 mins for delivery but it's always here in 15 mins. 10/10 - will order again!

Audrey Dalton (31 reviews)

14 Jan 2026

Source: Google

3.0

Not so good tonight..pizza not very hot fries not cooked enough so much so they stuck together with the startch Your normally our go to place

Restaurant response

Response added on 14 Jan 2026

Hi Audrey, we are very sorry about the experience you had with us today. I would like to offer you 50% off on your next order. We appreciate you as a customer, and thank you for your review which will help us improve the quality and service.