We visited this neighborhood restaurant for the first time to celebrate a special occasion. The concept is charming - a café by day and a restaurant by night. Unfortunately, the experience took a disappointing turn once the food arrived. We ordered two rib steaks: one medium rare and one medium well. The medium well steak came out severely overcooked. The first bite tasted burnt, and the meat was tough. I even gave a small piece to a family member before sending it back, just to confirm it wasn’t just me. While waiting for a replacement, we were served mocktails, which we mistakenly took as a thoughtful service. The replacement steak arrived. Although not burnt, it still was not medium well, but closer to well done. I took a few bites and disappointed, I asked to bring the rest home. When it was time to pay, the waiter informed us he had “done his best” by offering a 15% discount on the first burnt steak as well as the complimentary mocktails. I was honestly shocked that we were being charged for it at all, given the repeated issues. My husband chose not to say anything, likely to avoid making a scene, but the situation left a sour impression. The kitchen’s inability to cook steaks to the requested doneness and the questionable billing practices are major concerns. If you decide to visit, beware! As for us, it was our first and last visit. Almost $300 for burnt steak, non merci ! That said, the kiddo enjoyed the cod sliders.
What guests say about Estiatorio Marmo
The reviews are overwhelmingly positive for Estiatorio Marmo, with a chic, polished atmosphere, warm and attentive service, and dishes often described as fresh, flavorful, and well presented. Several customers especially recommend the seafood, pasta, cocktails, and coffee, and return for the overall experience. A few reviews do mention fairly high prices and portions sometimes considered small. There is also at least one very negative comment about the doneness of the steaks, so the experience may vary depending on the dishes.
Reviews / Ratings for Estiatorio Marmo
Cafe Fredo is absolutely OUT OF THIS WORLD !!! What a great addition to the area 👏
Nice decor and ambiance, sufficient menu to order from, food was very good and espresso martini was excellent. Overall great experience.
Amazing experience! The food was fresh, flavorful, and beautifully presented. The service was friendly and attentive, and the atmosphere was warm and inviting. Definitely coming back!
What a great night we had Friday. Food. Drinks. Everything was so well presented and fresh. Overall 10/5. Highly recommend
Very respectful very responsible and organized very much recommend
SUCH A WONDERFUL RESTAURANT, HONESTLY THE BEST OF THE BEST FOOD, AND THE OWNERS ARE REALLY WELCOMING. I TRULY LOVE THAT PLACE. DEFINITELY RECOMMEND IT
Amazing dinner experience. The fish was amazing, the pasta was so simple but so good. Definitely one of my top spots in Montreal.
Great albeit pricey for the area.
The restaurant is very chic and clean! The food was amazing as well! Very good portions! Our waitress was very nice and took great care of us! Definitely worth a try! I had the filet mignon and the lemon butter champagne linguine!
A+++++ definetly a must and great addition to the neighborhood! Quality +++
Absolutely outstanding Mediterranean food. Every dish we ordered was fresh, flavorful, and perfectly prepared. You can tell great care goes into both the ingredients and the cooking. The portions were generous, the presentation was beautiful, and everything tasted incredible. Service was friendly and attentive, and the overall atmosphere made the experience even better. Easily one of the best Mediterranean meals I’ve had—highly recommended.
Good restaurant! I liked the atmosphere inside and there’s good food options. As someone who enjoys films, I found the references in the restaurant funny. The menu is a bit on the pricier side as the portions are not huge. We got the burrata and salmon tartare to share, and I had the pasta of the day. Everything was to our liking!
Reviews are also available in French.
See reviews in FrenchAdd a review
Share your experience in seconds.
Opening hours
- Sunday Closed
- Monday Closed
- Tuesday Closed
- Wednesday 17:00 - 22:00
- Thursday 17:00 - 23:00
- Friday Closed
- Saturday Closed
Features
Missing information?
Help us improve this restaurant profile.
Update the profile